[MizunoJoe]

You need a crash course in physics. The only way to produce and maintain different hand path and ch path is to apply force across the shaft. But you say Hogan was only pulling. And moving hands and ch on entirely different planes through impact. It doesn't add up.

Crash-bang: Applying FATS in a Swing is OK as long as it isn't applied in the wrong place on the shaft. In fact, all Swings require it or the Pivot couldn't move the club. You're mistakenly thinking that pulling just means pulling longitudinally on the shaft.

When Hogan "slots" the shaft, the hand pressure is downward and perpendicular to the plane of the left wrist. He flattens the shaft and whirls through impact, keeping his hands moving in an ever tightening curved path around his body rather than letting the pivot throw them away from the body down the line as in a cf Swing.