[golfer24]

Sounds to me you would benefit more from a sports pychiatrist than an instructor. Probably spelt that wrong.

You have received some top advice from the guys here. You obviously film your swing does it look different when you try these different swings. If you are so inconsistent then surely the only reason is throwaway in your swing. Maybe you can time it well somedays and others not so good. Find the proceedure that gets best results when viewed on tape and stick with it.