[comdpa]

Your point is a very good one, wish Id said that. Your Freudian slip, assuming it was a slip, on the spelling of your nom de plume is priceless. Never would have thought a discussion about golf geometry would come around to a story about a guy named Bumby entering a room with sh!t covered walls! This is one of heck of a thread!

comdpa's been around for a while .... I like him, just wondering whats up? Doesnt sound like him. Maybe we been hacked ? Divide and concur? Mike O. might be behind all of this.

Relax homies, we are not hacked. Its just me thinking out loud. If the plane is the be all and end all of the swing, then how do we explain the difference between the following picture. Thanks for liking me...perhaps you could like me also on my Facebook page...Asian Golf Institute. And as you have correctly pointed out, I have been around awhile so the intention is not to stir shit but to discuss.



Uploaded with ImageShack.us

Ok , NO to the high speed video thing. That didnt come along till recently. Agreed on the feel thing theoretically but he sure wrote some wonderful stuff about feel for a mid handicapper, no? I like it , obviously.

So what are you feeling and seeing on high speed then?

Perhaps the best way to answer your question would be to reference the image posted above. Before high frames per second video became available, it was hard to pinpoint subtle moves of say the shoulders and hips in unison during the transition.

I have benefited from Mr. Kelley's magnus opus and have declared that many times on this site.

However, I believe that while Mr. Kelley has addressed the descriptive portion of the swing, he has left the explanatory portion of the swing to the Certified Instructors the likes of Lynn. Therefore, it is very unlikely that one would be able to use the yellow book effectively without a Certified Instructor as Mr. Kelley has advised against.