Originally Posted by Daryl
|
This is a good example of a Rotated Shoulder Turned and Clubshaft and Hands on the Elbow Plane. His Right Forearm is significantly “Off” Plane while his Right Elbow is “On” Plane. In order for His Hands to continue down the Plane of his Clubshaft, Hogan must Unbend (lengthen) his Right Arm else, his Hands will come in above the Plane.
So, its very easy to have your Clubshaft on one plane, your hands on the same plane, your Right Elbow on the same Plane but your Right Forearm OFF Plane.
The reality of this Elbow Plane tragedy is that his hands should be about 3 inches further down the Red Plain Line so that his Right Forearm can be On Plane. If you want to Swing on the Elbow Plane, AND, have your Hands, Clubshaft, Right Elbow and RIGHT FOREARM on the same plane, you need a really short stroke.
Furthermore, Hogan Cannot Trace the same Plane line until his Hands reach Release when his Right Forearm becomes On Plane. You CANNOT Unbend the Right Elbow while Tracing the Plane Line with THE RIGHT FOREARM FLYING WEDGE. 
|
D, I love ya but I think there is some stuff here that is just "plane" confusing for me. I know that is not out of the norm for me, but lets talk about which "plane" you are referring to here.
I'd say the Right Forearm, indeed the entire RFFW ideally stays "on plane", so to speak, throughout the entire swing. But this is the plane of the Right Wrist Bend not to be confused with The Inclined Plane which the right forearm rides sometimes through impact say, but not always. So at top the RFFW is not on the Inclined Plane in Total Motion. Chipping maybe. See 6-B-3-0-1.
On the other hand, Per 10-6-0. The Inclined Plane, Basic Plane Angles, clubshaft control; "Basic Plane Angles are classified according to reference points on which the Inclined Plane can be set". May I add that I believe this to mean at Address for the elbow plane, Top for the Turned Shoulder plane. Meaning if Homer set his plane board to a fixed angle that referenced the Elbow, (the Elbow Plane) the entire Right Forearm , including the elbow and the clubshaft would lay on this fixed plane angle at Address, only. Once you reach Top or End the right Elbow moves under the Inclined Plane, "Elbow Plane". see photos 10-6-A 1 and 2.
Sorry if I'm misunderstanding your post , I can be totally vapidiculous sometimes.