[EdZ]

Daryl

Was that click I was hearing the right impact sound?
Should there be noticeable divots past the ball with just basic motion, or just a small one?

Yes - the 'click' is a very good thing. On short shots, a click, on full shots - the sound of a rifle shot. (sizzle)

Divots are a good thing. The low point of the clubhead is under the ground, in front of the ball, so even short shots can have a divot (or at least show that you hit down to the ground, a scuff for a chip). Not a big chunk, but a smooth fairly thin divot. (wide thin divots for full shots a few inches long).

Focus on that 'click'. You can both feel, and hear, a good shot, from the putter to the driver.